Lyle’s rewritten half a dozen verse text message is roughly parallel with the songster text immediately after deletion of your own fourth verse of your own second. Lyle’s rewritten version, although not, provides the routine browsing Kilkenny, as opposed to Killarney. Lyle including composed a separate tune for the track, provided throughout the really works cited, and you can released prior to which have sounds. Lyle’s tune is actually “The fresh Bonnie Bluish Forget-Me-Not,” which had been given when you look at the Roentgen. An excellent. Smith’s Brand new Irish Minstrel , letter.d. [1825, the initial, supposedly pent up, edition]. The latest term of your tune is there provided given that “The brand new Housemaid out of Derby.” If you find yourself Lyle’s text “Rather Peg from Derby” is actually meaningless since the a traditional tune, we could make certain “Rather Peggy off Derby” was sung from inside the Scotland in the first one-fourth of the nineteenth century having a book much like one regarding the songster. [Incongrously, Lyle’s text as opposed to good chapbook otherwise broadside backup looks Roy Palmer’s current Everyman’s Book out-of Ballads. ]
Perhaps slightly before “Very Peggy regarding Derby, O” try rewritten because the “This new Bonnie Lass o’ Fyvie” as confirmed by the a duplicate from inside the Peter Buchan’s MSS throughout the Uk Collection, which happen to be thought to day regarding the 1828.
The first line and a half, almost like the individuals over, are also for the an excellent medley inside Vol. I, p. cuatro, 1825. You’ll find sounds to your tune “Quite Peggy out-of Derby, O” to the p. 107 and you may 276 away from Vol. III, 1828, and the first-line off “Peggy off Darby” is actually an excellent medley to your p. 284.
Cahusac in the 1788, and an individual sheet track that have sounds is in a few Western selections, “Peggy away from Darby”, and this kicks off “There is certainly a gay Chief during the Darby City”
T. Crofton Crocker on the Popular Songs regarding Ireland , London area, 1839, p. 124 (p. 121 from 1886 reprint), states, “The fresh new fairly Housemaid away from Derby, O!” is proven to be the manufacture of an Irishman, however, become brings zero specifics almost any, not really bringing up where a copy of your own text otherwise song will be discovered. It seems that Crocker expected his readers as familiar toward track and song. The evidence cited over appears to lovingwomen.org Klik pГҐ dette link me to become slightly definitive to take “Rather Peggy regarding Derby” are an Irish track and you will song. Devoid of that it evidence, not, there are counterclaims. Wm. Chappell during the Songs of your own Olden Go out , II, p. 771, indexed Crocker’s allege, however, suggested your track was not Irish, however, the guy supplied zero direct facts. Chappell’s statement you to Bunting rejected it’s without basis. Bunting don’t speak about brand new tune, that’s certainly not the same as stating the guy denied they. off Grove’s Dictionary , however, alludes to no facts pro or swindle, so we do not know what research he previously viewed, or no.
Lastly, two things We have not yet seen. There can be a duplicate of your pay attention a beneficial flute tutor compiled by T. BUCEM listing no content from the regarding the British Countries.
Donnal O’Sullivan, concurs which have Chappell within his post on Irish Folk-music into the the fresh 5th ed
Unrelated: “Falls out-of Brandy” try a much earlier not related song from similar title, also called “Dribbles out of Brandy.” Aforementioned title Thomson’s track towards the tune in his Edinburgh ballad opera ‘The Distressed Gallant’, 1738. A couple of years later this song is actually copied with the NLS MS 6299. The newest track you certainly will admission to the modern you to on the track when we failed to remember that the new song try before. “The fresh new Dandy, O,” Thomas Moore’s song to possess his track “Young Will get Moonlight” in fifth amount of Irish Tunes , n.d. was a separate listen six/8 day which have identical identity, evidently offered by Moore regarding the chorus out of a track from inside the Robin Bonnet in which the tune seemed in place of title.
